The Songs of Bill Withers Find New Life in a Tribute That Gives Something Back
There are some songwriters whose music becomes so much a part of our lives that we almost forget who wrote the songs in the first place. Bill Withers was one of them.
His songs have been played at weddings, funerals, family gatherings and on countless late-night drives. They've been covered by everyone from soul singers to blues musicians, and more than half a century after they were first recorded, they still have the ability to stop you in your tracks.
There's a simplicity to Withers' songwriting that has always been part of its appeal. He didn't need elaborate arrangements or complicated lyrics to get his point across. Whether it was the loneliness of ‘Ain't No Sunshine’, the reassurance of ‘Lean On Me’ or the easy warmth of ‘Lovely Day’, he had a remarkable ability to put everyday emotions into words that seemed to belong to everyone.
Now, some of those songs are finding their way into new hands, with a collection of musicians coming together for 'Who Is He And What Is He To You?', a tribute album celebrating Withers' music while raising money for the Sweet Relief Musicians Fund.
The record arrives on vinyl through Flatiron Recordings on 27 November as a Record Store Day Black Friday exclusive, with proceeds supporting musicians and music industry workers who need assistance with healthcare and other essential living expenses. Produced by Grammy Award-winning producer Sheldon Gomberg, the project has been five years in the making and brings together 20 interpretations of songs from across Withers' catalogue.
Two of the latest recordings to emerge from the album come from Rickie Lee Jones and Ben Harper, artists whose own musical journeys have been shaped by many of the same American roots traditions that informed Withers' work.
Jones has taken on ‘Ain't No Sunshine’, one of the most recognisable songs of the early 1970s and a recording that helped introduce Withers to the world. It's a song that has been covered countless times, yet its strength has always been in what it leaves unsaid, allowing the emotion to sit in the spaces between the words.
For Jones, Withers was an artist who never seemed particularly interested in becoming a celebrity, despite writing some of the most enduring songs of his generation.
‘Bill Withers is the rarest of birds’, she says. ‘He was a songwriter, a hit maker, a recording artist whose songs are more famous than he. He simply never became a superstar the way the other songwriters, hit makers did. That makes him very special to me’.
She remembers first encountering his music in the early 1970s, when Withers seemed to exist somewhere between the folk movement, the blues tradition and the everyday working lives of the people he sang about.
‘He wanted to reach everyone. He did not want it to be about him, and his selfless messages are testament to that’.
Her choice of ‘Ain't No Sunshine’ is also deeply personal. The song's familiar sense of longing and uncertainty is something she understands from her own experience.
‘I chose this song because it's one of his best and, for me personally, I also have a sense of what life is like in the dark … wondering if she will ever be coming home’.
Ben Harper brings another perspective to the project with his interpretation of ‘Who Is He (And What Is He To You)?’, a song that reveals the darker, more suspicious side of Withers' songwriting.
Harper recorded the track with his band and Bernard Blackmon, who played guitar with Withers, creating a direct musical connection between the original recordings and this new interpretation.
‘I've always loved Bill Withers' music, and getting the chance to record it with my band, and Bill Withers' original guitar player, Bernard Blackmon, was a great experience’, Harper says.
For an artist whose own music has moved comfortably between blues, soul, folk and rock, Withers' catalogue is familiar territory. But Harper is equally enthusiastic about the reason behind the recording.
‘Doing it to help Sweet Relief, who helps musicians in need, makes it feel even better. I'm proud to be among so many great musicians, artists and friends contributing to this tribute record’.
The Sweet Relief Musicians Fund has spent years helping musicians and people working behind the scenes in the music industry when illness, injury or financial hardship makes life difficult. It's an important organisation in a business where even successful careers don't always provide the financial security people might imagine.
The charity has previously brought musicians together for tribute recordings, using the music of influential artists to raise funds while introducing their songs to new audiences.
For this latest collection, Gomberg has assembled a line-up that reflects the remarkable reach of Withers' songwriting.
Ruthie Foster opens the album with ‘Grandma's Hands’, a song that remains one of Withers' most personal recordings. Written about his grandmother, it draws on memories of family, childhood and the quiet strength of someone whose influence stays with you long after they're gone. Foster's background in blues and gospel makes her a natural fit for the material.
Rickie Lee Jones follows with ‘Ain't No Sunshine’, before Jonah Tolchin takes on ‘Ruby Lee’ and Lady Blackbird brings her distinctive voice to ‘Use Me’, one of Withers' great groove-driven recordings.
Harper's version of ‘Who Is He (And What Is He To You)?’ sits alongside Charles Jones' ‘Sweet Wanomi’, Eric Gales' interpretation of ‘Kissing My Love’ and David Ryan Harris' take on ‘Harlem’, a song that captures the rhythmic energy of Withers' early recordings.
There's also a particularly interesting family connection on Chris Stills' version of ‘The Same Love That Made Me Laugh’. His father, Stephen Stills, played lead guitar on Withers' 1971 debut album, 'Just As I Am', bringing a little of that original musical history into the new project.
Beth Hart takes on ‘Lean On Me’, a song whose message of friendship and looking after one another feels especially appropriate for a record supporting musicians in need. Alethea Mills contributes ‘Hello Like Before’, while Chris Pierce explores the darker territory of ‘Better Off Dead’.
Elsewhere, Eli Smart offers his interpretation of ‘Lovely Day’, Chavonne Stewart performs ‘Lonely Town, Lonely Street’, and Marilyn McCoo and Billy Davis Jr. revisit ‘Just the Two of Us’, bringing their own history in soul music to one of Withers' best-loved songs.
Australian singer Jade MacRae is also part of the collection, performing ‘Friend of Mine’, while Buffalo Nichols strips ‘I Don't Want You On My Mind’ back to a solo country-blues arrangement. It's an interesting reminder of how closely Withers' music was connected to the blues, even when his records were finding success on the soul and pop charts.
Sugaray Rayford contributes ‘World Keeps Going Round’, Jeff Young tackles ‘I Can't Write Left-Handed’, and Tina Schlieske closes the collection with ‘Hope She'll Be Happier With Him’.
Taken together, the 20 recordings offer a broader picture of Withers than the handful of hits most people know. There are songs about love, jealousy, regret, family, loneliness and hope, all delivered with the sort of directness that made his writing so distinctive.
Withers came to the recording industry relatively late, releasing 'Just As I Am' in 1971 after spending years working outside music. That experience gave his songwriting a perspective that was different from many of his contemporaries. He wasn't trying to invent a character or chase a particular image. He wrote about ordinary people and familiar emotions, often drawing on experiences that could just as easily have belonged to the person listening.
His recordings were rooted in soul, blues, gospel and folk, but they never sat comfortably inside one category. Songs such as ‘Ain't No Sunshine’, ‘Lean On Me’, ‘Use Me’ and ‘Lovely Day’ crossed musical boundaries almost effortlessly, becoming standards that would be reinterpreted by generations of performers.
Recognition followed over the years, including induction into the Songwriters Hall of Fame in 2005 and the Rock & Roll Hall of Fame in 2015, where Stevie Wonder helped honour his contribution to American music. ‘Lean On Me’ was inducted into the Grammy Hall of Fame in 2007, another acknowledgement of a song whose message has travelled far beyond its original recording.
Withers died on 30 March 2020 at the age of 81, leaving behind a relatively modest recording catalogue compared with many of his contemporaries, but one whose influence continues to reach across generations and musical styles.
For Gomberg, who has spent five years bringing this tribute together, the lasting appeal of Withers' music comes down to something that can't easily be manufactured in a recording studio.
‘His songwriting was genuine, simple and straight-ahead — just honest’, he says. ‘You relate to him. I'd known the big hits since I was a kid and loved those songs. And they're still standing the test of time’.
It's difficult to argue with that. There aren't many songwriters whose work can move so naturally from a blues club to a church choir, from a family celebration to a quiet moment alone, without losing any of its meaning.
And there's something particularly fitting about a Bill Withers tribute album helping musicians who find themselves in difficult circumstances. So much of his music was built around the importance of human connection, understanding and being there when someone needs a hand.
With artists such as Rickie Lee Jones, Ben Harper, Ruthie Foster, Beth Hart, Lady Blackbird, Eric Gales and Jade MacRae bringing their own voices to these songs, 'Who Is He And What Is He To You?' is more than an exercise in nostalgia. It's a reminder of just how much good songwriting can endure, and how music can continue to serve a purpose beyond the record itself.
Bill Withers never needed to make things complicated. He understood that sometimes the simplest words carry the greatest weight, particularly when they're written from somewhere genuine.
More than 50 years after his first recordings, those songs are still finding new voices, new audiences and, in this case, a way to help the people who keep music alive.
'Who Is He And What Is He To You? A Sweet Relief Tribute to Bill Withers' is released on vinyl through Flatiron Recordings on 27 November as a Record Store Day Black Friday exclusive, with proceeds benefiting the Sweet Relief Musicians Fund https://www.sweetrelief.org/.
'Rickie Lee Jones' ‘Ain't No Sunshine’ and Ben Harper's ‘Who Is He And What Is He To You?’ are available to stream now.'
Listen Now
Denim Sounds Good
Listen to the latest tracks, new releases and old favourites.
